What does research tell us about families with children with Down syndrome?
There have been a number of useful studies of the experiences of families with children with Down syndrome in recent years, particularly in Australia, the USA, and the UK. These studies have moved on from simply looking for negative effects and have taken more sophisticated approaches to involving families in their studies and trying to capture a realistic view of the experiences of families.
The range and types of research
The largest and most detailed study is the longitudinal study of families with children with Down syndrome which has been ongoing in Manchester, UK, since 1973. This research program was established by Cliff Cunningham, and he and his colleagues are still working with many of the families and the young adults with Down syndrome to continue to document their experiences. Their work has looked at both the influence of caring for a child with Down syndrome on the life of the family and the influence of family environments and parenting strategies on the development and progress of the child with Down syndrome. The Manchester studies have mainly investigated the variation in family experiences within a large group of families of children with Down syndrome. They have been able to ask if some families fare better than others and, if so, why? Importantly, they have also been able to see if families continue to do well or to experience stress over time, as they looked at families experiences at two points five years apart.
Other studies have compared the experiences of families with a child with Down syndrome with the experiences of other families with similar numbers of children and similar family characteristics, but not a child with a disability. These studies are important as they allow us to identify the possible differences associated with caring for a child with Down syndrome. Parenting is demanding and many families of young children find parenting stressful at times is it actually any different if one child has Down syndrome and, if so, how?
Research with families of children with Down syndrome
- Most (70%) of families adapt and lead ordinary family lives.
- Most families report benefits of having a child with Down syndrome for the whole family.
- Marriage breakdown is no more frequent than for the rest of the population it may even be less frequent.
- Brothers and sisters do not have more problems than in other families and are likely to be more caring.
- Resilient families tend to use practical coping strategies they seek out information and services. They join parent support groups.
- Resilient families develop a supportive emotional climate and encourage open communication between family members.
- Aging parents of adults with Down syndrome still living at home have better physical health and life satisfaction than typical aging parents.
- Some families (30%) are vulnerable and experience considerable stress. In these families, everyone may be affected by practical, emotional and behavioral difficulties the child with Down syndrome, brothers and sisters and parents.
- Vulnerable families can usually be identified in the first years of a childs’ life and will benefit from specific support from relatives, parent support groups and professional services.
Some studies have focused on the experience of brothers and sisters of children with Down syndrome. Most studies have assessed the experience of mothers only but some have included fathers and found that parents do not always have the same views of their families and the issues which cause stress! The needs of fathers have received much less attention than the needs of mothers. A few studies have considered the needs of grandparents and the role that grandparents can play in supporting families or increasing family stress.
Almost all research studies have used questionnaires completed by parents as their main method of data collection, though a few have used more open interview techniques to collect information from parents.
Most research has focused on the childhood years and most studies have visited just once and, therefore, obtained a snapshot view of life at that time. One group of researchers in the US have been following the experiences of families with adult children with Down syndrome still living at home with increasingly aging parents. This study has highlighted many positive outcomes and we are beginning to be able to build a life span perspective of families caring for individuals with Down syndrome.
The majority of researchers have only worked with families from Western or European cultures, in the US, Australia and the UK. This means that the findings cannot be assumed to reflect the experiences of families with different cultural backgrounds. A few studies have looked at Chinese families and Latino families but published information on experiences in cultures other than western ones is limited. We would expect some issues to be similar and some different, based on the current state of knowledge.
The main findings are positive
Most families do well. The main finding of research studies is normality the majority of families with children with Down syndrome lead ordinary lives. This does not mean that families do not have additional demands and challenges to cope with. It means that at least 65-70% of families find the resources to meet the additional needs of their child or adult with Down syndrome and lead happy and ordinary family lives themselves. There are no more marriage breakdowns than in the rest of the population (and some indication that breakdown is less likely).
There is no evidence of ill effects for brothers and sisters in these families and both parents and brothers and sisters report benefits as well as extra demands. As a group, families with children and adults with Down syndrome report less stress than families with children with similar levels of intellectual disabilities from other causes. There may be several reasons for this, such as early diagnosis and support, information which helps parents to predict the future, the sociable and warm nature of most children and adults with Down syndrome and fewer behavior problems than in the comparison groups.
There is some evidence that aging parents who have adults with Down syndrome still living at home have better physical health and life satisfaction than aging adults in the typical population.
Where researchers have had comparison groups of families without a child with a disability, they find few differences on measures of resilience or family functioning, even though mothers of children with Down syndrome report more parenting demands and more stresses. This supports the view that most parents cope with the extra demands and stresses effectively and that the family does not suffer.
Some families have a hard time. If 65-70% of families are doing fine, there are 30-35% of families who are showing signs of considerable stress or distress, for a variety of reasons. In these families, brothers, sisters and the child with Down syndrome are more likely to show behavior difficulties. Parents are more likely to be struggling to cope and experiencing depression or health problems. All family relationships will be strained and family life affected. Some of the reasons that lead to families having a hard time have been identified and this information may be able to help parents, extended families and services to pinpoint their needs and ways to improve their situation if life is difficult to manage at present.
As the reader will see, almost all the factors that make families with children with Down syndrome vulnerable will make any family vulnerable and parenting more difficult. The same characteristics lead to family and child difficulties in the rest of the population.
Family strengths and weaknesses. Researchers have identified at least some of the factors that help families to cope well and some of the factors that make families vulnerable to stress. These can be described as strengths factors which increase resilience, and weaknesses factors which increase vulnerability. Resilience is the term used to describe the family’s ability to cope in the face of life stresses. Resilience and vulnerability factors are discussed in the next section.
This information is particularly important for new families, those with preschool children and those who provide services and support in the early years, as the evidence from the Manchester studies and others suggest that the most vulnerable families will experience difficulties from the time the news is broken and, without help, will continue to experience difficulties affecting all members of the family.
Resilience and vulnerability
The following section presents an overview of the factors found to influence the resilience of families from the available published research, in order to try to interpret what is known and to draw out the implications for families and for service providers. The main findings are illustrated in diagrammatic form in Figure 2 to try to help the reader to co-ordinate the findings and to see how they relate to a family’s experience. Putting them onto one diagram allows us to see the full picture. It is important to note that strengths and weaknesses are likely to be additive. Families with several vulnerability factors will be worse off than families with only one, and areas of strength may be able to compensate for areas of vulnerability. It is important to bear this in mind as we discuss each possible strength or weakness. On its own, one weakness may not put a family at risk, as other factors in the life of the family or support from services may compensate.
It is also important to note that research studies have not assessed all the possible influences on families resilience or sources of stress. For example, the unconditional love that almost all parents feel for their child, and the way in which family members value the child is a major source of resilience. Advocating for their children’s needs leads many parents to report that they have discovered new strengths, made new and lasting friendships and that they have become more involved in their communities. These all have benefits for their lives, and increase their resilience in the face of other life events that are part of the life experience of most people. Parents often report that dealing with service providers is a major source of stress: these issues have not been well documented in the published research studies.
Research studies also report main differences between groups of families and they tend to conceal the range of individual differences within their group data. The research then leads to generalizations about families with a child with a disability. These may be helpful to alert us to important issues, but the reader is encouraged to remember that all families are different, with their own characteristics and ways of supporting each other, and that all families change and develop over time.
What parents of teenagers with Down syndrome actually say about their lives
“Though we were devastated when he was born, he was such a happy child, and relatively little trouble, apart from illness, that we soon realized we wouldn’t be without him. Though there has been stressful and worrying times (notably age 10-12) he has added another dimension to our lives, and I’m sure we met a lot of people, done a lot of things that we wouldn’t have done otherwise. He is popular, friendly and non-judgemental and all in all the positive effects outweigh the bad.”
“Very loving, trusting and happy boy enjoys life and is very sociable. Cannot always do things we would like to do, he takes up a lot of time. Unable to work full-time in my career so have to accept a job which accommodates his needs.”
“Sometimes we have been restricted in our activities. When my sons were younger there was a certain amount of embarrassment when their peer groups would make derogatory remarks to them.”
46 families took part in a survey, part of which covered effects on family life, brothers and sisters, and the need for services. A summary of the findings and the full range of their verbatim views is included as an Appendix.
The individual characteristics of parents
Personalities. Certain personality characteristics seem to make individuals more vulnerable when faced with demanding life events. Individuals who score highly on measures of neuroticism or anxiety seem to be less able to cope in a positive and effective manner. Individuals with low self-esteem or self-confidence will be less likely to believe that they have the ability to cope. Individuals who are more extraverted, and those that have a strong sense of being in control of their lives (internal locus of control), manage stressful life events more effectively than individuals who are more introverted and tend to feel that what happens to them is outside their control (external locus of control). Personality characteristics may affect the different coping strategies that are used by parents. For example, at a time when a parent is anxious and has low self-esteem, he or she is unlikely to seek out social support or to develop active, problem solving strategies.
Coping strategies. Coping strategies are the ways in which individuals deal with stressful situations. In the family research, they have been divided into emotion focused and practically focused strategies. In the main, practical coping strategies seem to be positive and linked with resilience. These may be described as active problem solving strategies which include seeking information about Down syndrome and about services, benefits and support available to the family, meeting other parents and joining a support group, and making full use of family and community social support networks. Emotion focused strategies include wishful thinking (maybe things will get better), passive acceptance (this is my lot in life and I have to put up with it) and stoical thinking (making light of the issues without doing anything practical). Emotion focused coping is reported to lead to stress and vulnerability but this may be an oversimplification of the issues. The type of strategy that is positive may depend on whether it is possible to change a stressful situation or not, and the needs of parents at particular times.
Cognitive appraisal and adjustment. Researchers and parents have identified that the way in which we think and make sense of life events is an important part of the process of adjustment, and that adjustment takes time. The individual way in which we think about and interpret life events is an important part of coping positively or negatively and will also influence our feelings and emotions. The way in which we react to the news that our baby has Down syndrome will be influenced by the beliefs of our community and our individual beliefs. If we believe that the baby is a punishment for sin or a disgrace on the family, we will feel and think differently from someone who sees this as a chance occurrence which could happen to anyone and not an event to be ashamed of. If we are told that the baby will never make much progress and always be dependent, then we will find it hard to think positively about the future.
Factors that make families vulnerable
- Poverty, poor housing, no car, and unemployment – these disadvantages make parenting more difficult in any family.
- Poor marital relationships, disharmony in the family.
- Personal resources, low self-esteem and self-confidence, passive and ineffective coping strategies.
- Poor parent-child relationship with child with Down syndrome – emotional ambivalence towards the child.
- Difficulties with control and behavior management.
- The demands of parenting a child with Down syndrome who has atypical difficulties such as:
- persistent behavior or sleep difficulties
- more severe developmental delays
- chronic health difficulties
- acute, life threatening, health difficulties
- a difficult temperament e.g. restless, over-active, impulsive
Services and support
- Limited family and social support.
- Inadequate services
For all parents there will be a period of adjustment, since they had a set of expectations for their healthy baby which they now have to change to take account of the fact that their baby has Down syndrome. Some parents will find it easier to reconstruct their hopes for their child and their future than others, and this will be influenced by their underlying personality characteristics. It may also be influenced by their previous experience of coping with stressful life events.
To identify that evaluating the positive or negative effects of coping strategies are more complex than the researchers often indicate, we can consider some examples.
Optimism and hope are reported by parents as important and positive coping strategies and some of those hopes may later turn out to have been over-optimistic. However, at the time, that level of hope was essential to feeling able to cope. Is that hope, at that point, wishful thinking? If so, wishful thinking was a positive, rather than a negative strategy, at that time.
Similarly, when is acceptance helpful and part of positive cognitive adjustment (or coming to terms with the situation) because we have now made a realistic appraisal of our situation and determined what we can or cannot change? When is it passive acceptance and thought to be unhelpful?
When is active practical coping helpful and when is it not helpful? Most of the time it seems that it is a helpful way to go forward, but it will not be helpful if parents seek out practical therapy programs which hold out false hope and place enormous strain on the resources of the family in terms of time and money. (This is more likely to happen when services have little to offer.)
Marital relationships. The quality of the relationship between parents has been shown to be important. The way in which mothers feel supported emotionally in the relationship, the practical involvement of father in child care and in the decision making regarding the child are all important factors. Mothers have reported the importance of good father-child relationships when asked to judge how well they think that their family is functioning. Fathers also report that their relationship with their partner and the quality of their family life is important. Positive relationships between partners reduces the stress they experience.
Family cohesion and harmony. The quality of the relationships within the family, the emotional warmth, the care shared between family members and the ability to communicate effectively all influence family well-being. This has been identified from questionnaire measures and from interviews with mothers that allowed them to identify what was important without any leading questions from the interviewer. In cohesive families, there is generally a happy atmosphere, everyone is valued and respected, the achievements of each person are celebrated and the family enjoy shared activities and being together. In cohesive families, mothers, fathers and all family members report less stress.
The practical and financial resources of families influence their ability to cope with the demands of parenting. Poor housing, poverty, lack of transport (a car) and unemployment all increase family vulnerability. The impact of these factors may be more stressful when one child has Down syndrome, as poverty and lack of transport may reduce the opportunities to access support groups and services. The lack of practical resources for laundry and adequate heating are also more significant.
As might be expected, the physical and mental health of parents has been shown to influence family situations. It is important that parents are aware of their own needs and take care of themselves. In terms of mental health, a number of studies report increased levels of stress for both mothers and fathers in families with a child with Down syndrome sometimes using mental health measures such as depression questionnaires. However, these are usually small increases in stress and very few parents actually score in the clinically depressed range. Some studies suggest that different factors affect fathers and mothers. Mothers are more stressed by childcare issues and worries about how the family is functioning, while fathers are more worried about the financial and practical needs of the family. These findings are, of course, to be interpreted in the context of the family role expectations in the communities being studied.
Employment for mothers
Employment needs to be considered in more depth as the effects of unemployment for mothers and fathers may be different. For fathers, unemployment may lead to serious poverty for the family and all the usual negative consequences for the individual, undermining self-respect and fathers role in the family. For mothers, being unemployed and staying at home with children does not necessarily have negative effects as it may be the typical role for women in the community or seen as a positive choice.
However, for mothers of children with Down syndrome, employment outside the home has been shown in several studies to be a positive and protective factor. Working mothers report less stress and more life satisfaction despite the extra demands of work, child care and family. This beneficial effect of employment when coping with demanding life events has also been shown in studies of depression in women. Working outside the home provides social contacts and friends, a different role, a change of daily demands and an increase in income. Unfortunately fewer mothers of children with Down syndrome continue to work (56% compared to 76% of mothers without a disabled child in one study). This is a finding with clear practical implications and one that many mothers may find reassuring if they wish to continue to work.
Some children with Down syndrome may be more difficult to care for than others and place extra demands on all members of the family, especially parents. The reader will note that most of these characteristics may also be seen in children without disabilities and will also cause increased parenting demands for their families.
Health issues. The needs of children with acute illness or chronic illness, requiring hospitalization or hospital visits and treatment will cause additional stress or demands within families. For example, if a child has a chronic heart problem, chronic bowel condition or childhood leukemia, this will cause significant additional stress.
All children with Down syndrome have additional health needs and this leads to more hospital appointments and often more illness than that experienced by typically developing children. However, in the research studies, it is when the healthcare needs of the child with Down syndrome are more significant and serious than they are for the majority of children with Down syndrome that they increase the family’s vulnerability.
Temperament. The demands of children with hyperactive, excitable or difficult temperaments will be more difficult to manage than most other children with Down syndrome. Children with more difficult temperaments are more likely to have feeding, sleeping and behavior difficulties and will be less likely to be able to occupy themselves. These children may be particularly demanding for first time parents to cope with.
Development. Families with children with Down syndrome who have more significantly delayed development, children with multiple difficulties (additional physical difficulties or brain damage) or children with autistic difficulties experience and report more stress. There is a wide range of individual differences between children with Down syndrome in rates of progress and degree of disability. Some 11% have significantly more delayed development and the families of these children may face many more parenting demands.
Behavior Difficulties. Families with children with Down syndrome who have persistent behavior difficulties experience more stress. The evidence suggests that these families are as stressed as those with autistic children or children with other disabilities and similar levels of behavior difficulty. They do not show the comparatively lower stress pattern evident for most families with children with Down syndrome.
The evidence also suggests that persistent and disruptive behavior difficulties, while only seen in a minority of children, begin in the preschool years and continue during the school years. Therefore, intervention to help parents avoid these difficulties needs to be available in the preschool years.
Sleep. Families with children who have poor sleep patterns experience and report more stress. Sleep difficulties include settling problems, early waking and waking during the night. Night waking is reported as the most stressful as it results in broken sleep for both the child and the family. Studies also report a link between disturbed sleep and difficult daytime behavior. Sleep difficulties usually start during the preschool years and parents should be alert to the risks of long term sleep problems and seek help in managing problems as soon as they begin.
Attachment. In families where parents have found it difficult to bond with the baby with Down syndrome, more stress and more behavior difficulties are reported. Some parents do not find it easy to feel unconditional love for their baby with Down syndrome. They may struggle with conflicting feelings, predominantly negative, towards their child for many years. When this is the case, it may color parents perceptions of the child and make it hard for them to feel positive about the future. They may be more inclined to dwell on the problems that their child presents than on the child’s progress and achievements. The child in this situation will usually sense the negative feelings and be emotionally insecure. In the authors experience, this can lead to an increase in behavior problems from the early years. Sometimes the effects of the child’s insecurity are not fully expressed until adolescence, when he or she may express feelings by becoming aggressive or depressed.
Sources of support
Research suggests that the range of emotional and practical supports outside of the family influence family well-being. The range of such supports that an individual family or parent has will be influenced by the individual personalities and coping styles of parents. In other words, if parents are isolated then it is not enough to point out that more social networks will be helpful. The individual may not have the confidence to access these sources of support and may be uncomfortable relating to others in group support situations. Support for the individual parents personal needs will be helpful before he or she will be able to benefit from other social supports available in the local community. Seeking out social and practical support is generally described as helpful, without comparing the benefits of different sources of support. All the research on coping with stressful life events suggests that those who are socially isolated are more vulnerable and less likely to make positive adjustments.
Family and friends
The practical and emotional support provided by the extended family of grandparents, aunts and uncles can be a very positive source of support to parents and brother and sisters of children with Down syndrome. Equally, if grandparents cannot accept the baby and are pessimistic about the future then this will make the positive adjustment of parents more difficult. There is very little research on the role of grandparents but this does identify possible positive and negative effects. However, in the majority of families, the emotional and practical support provided by grandparents and other members of the extended family is usually a very important positive part of the family support network.
Social networks – church and community
The family’s existing networks of friends in the neighborhood, at church, play schools, mother and toddler groups, and at clubs in the community can be a very positive source of support, provided that they are positive about the child with Down syndrome and welcome him or her into their homes or activities. This is illustrated by parents reports of the support of their church – some have found the church members a positive help, others have found their church community negative and unhelpful. The beliefs that people have about disability and Down syndrome will influence their attitudes and this will apply to family members, friends and contacts in shops or on public transport. Too often parents report that they have to educate those around them, including some service providers! However, most families do find positive support in their local communities and benefit from this support.
Parent support networks
Many families report the benefits of joining parent support groups or Down syndrome associations and meeting other families with children with Down syndrome. Some parents report that the most significant emotional and practical help that they received came from other parents. In the first months and weeks, parents often report that it was helpful to meet other families who have got over the shock and feel positive about their child and the future. It was also helpful to see that they and their other children are leading ordinary lives. In parent groups, parents benefit from the sense of mutual understanding and they benefit from the practical tips and advice shared by those with older or similar age children. Parent groups can be a strong voice for action when services or legislation needs to change. The emotional and practical support of other parents can be extremely valuable when parents are fighting for services on behalf of their child.
However, these benefits will only be felt if parents find understanding and support from a local group. For example, parents with children who have more significant difficulties do not always feel that Down syndrome groups meet their needs. The group may be focusing on teaching children to speak and to read and getting them into mainstream schools and these goals may not seem appropriate at all to the parent of the more delayed child.
In the early days and months, one of the main things that parents seek is information. Part of the shock and emotional turmoil associated with getting the diagnosis is that it plunges parents into a world that they were not prepared for. Most parents feel that they know what to expect when parenting a healthy baby, but once they learn that the baby has Down syndrome they feel at a loss and sometimes as if they are no longer in control of their lives. Accurate information about the baby and young child’s needs and expected progress, and the availability of local services is usually reassuring and enables parents to begin to feel less distressed, to feel that they will cope and to feel more able to adjust positively.
Information can come in many ways at the present time. It may be written information, website information or verbal information from parents or service providers. It should always be positive while being realistic everyone needs hope for the future. There are a number of studies which document that way in which the diagnosis is initially presented to parents affects their long-term adjustment. Information needs to identify the strengths of children with Down syndrome, the fact that they are children first and need to be a much loved member of the family in order to flourish, like any other child, that families mainly cope very well, that life goes on and that most families report the benefits of raising a child with a disability as well as the extra demands.
Families in the communities where research studies have been carried out generally value the support that they have received from services, especially early support provided in the home. They particularly value services that provide them with practical and realistic strategies for dealing with difficulties.
However, parents value services when provided by professionals who value the child, respect the family, have good listening skills and are empathic, who are well informed and share their knowledge with parents in a positive and supportive manner.
In some studies, parents have reported that dealing with some of the professionals that they encounter because their child has a disability has been a major source of additional stress, rather than a source of support. The stress may be caused by the attitude of the professional and his or her way of working, or because parents have to fight with them to get the service that they want for their child. All too often, parents find that they know more about their child’s disability and current good practice than the professional and this identifies the importance of training programs in services. All too often, professionals do not work in a family centered way, respecting the right of families to identify what help they need, what will work for them and the hopes they have for the future for their child. Many professionals do not respect the fact that the quality of life-time care of an individual with Down syndrome depends on his or her family support whether or not he or she leaves the family home. Parenting is a life long commitment for all parents the roles change with age but parents and brothers and sisters play important life long roles in most peoples lives. The main goal of services should be to strengthen families and this theme will be extended in the later sections for families and for service providers. Many professionals play minor and short-lived roles in the life of a person with a disability but wield too much power in decision making relative to their actual responsibility or ongoing commitment to the individuals.
Practical support – respite and benefits
Support for the everyday demands of caring for a child can make a vital difference to the lives of families, and these can be financial contributions or practical services that sometimes relieve the demands of caring.
Many studies identify the extra financial costs of raising a child with a disability. Some costs are associated with child care needs wearing nappies for longer and needing more changes of clothes, for example and the costs of travel to hospital appointments, therapy services or parent groups. A major issue is reduced family income because it is more difficult for mothers to return to work. Full-time work is often impossible because school times do not fit in. When children are in special schools, the school day is often short and mothers have to be available at transport times. Children with disabilities need supervision for longer and the breakfast or after school clubs available for other children of working parents rarely take children with disabilities. Many countries recognize this financial burden and provide disability benefits of various kinds.
These financial contributions are valued by families and lead to an improved quality of life but there is a possible pitfall. Disability benefits are intended to meet the extra costs for the individual with disability but it is easy for them to become absorbed as part of the total family income. This can lead to difficulties when a teenager or young adult has the opportunity to take a residential education or vocational training course or to leave home to live independently of the family. The family may be reluctant to allow the young person to move on because the disability benefits will move with the person. It may help to alert families to this issue when children are young and encourage them to think of the benefit as separate from the general family income. Similar problems can arise when the family car has been funded by a disability fund.
Practical support for caring is valued by families, when it provides some respite from the daily demands and allows family members time to do things that may be difficult to do with a child with a disability, such as visiting a museum with other children or even shopping. It may also allow parents to simply relax and rest, especially if a child has a high level of behavior difficulty or care needs. Help in the home with sitting services, alternate family care, or respite care in a service facility can provide a life-line for families. There will also be benefits for the child as he or she will begin to feel safe away from home and gain friends and new social activities.
How families influence the development of children with Down syndrome
A small number of studies have looked at the progress of children with Down syndrome in relation to family characteristics and coping strategies. Like all children, the progress of children with Down syndrome is influenced by their family environment, and their educational and social opportunities, not just determined by their genetic makeup. Children with Down syndrome show the usual benefits of social class, with those in families with more resources and higher levels of parental education making better progress. They also show the same benefits of family position, with first and only children making better progress, presumably due to more individual adult attention.
In the Manchester studies, the findings indicate that progress in self-sufficiency (life skills) and practical skills were more influenced by family factors than academic progress. Higher self-sufficiency scores were achieved by children whose mothers used practical problem solving strategies and lower for those who tended to use wishful thinking, even after taking account of the effects of mental age on the children’s progress. As the children got older, the link between cognitive ability and life skills became weaker. Cognitive ability as measured by mental age predicted academic achievement but family factors and social opportunities had more influence on life skills.
After allowing for mental age and attentional difficulties, academic progress was better when mothers used practical and problem solving coping strategies to deal with child related problems, and worse in families where fathers tended towards an external locus of control, and therefore felt that they had little influence on events. Fathers active involvement with the child’s development and education has a positive effect on progress. (In an American study of families with a young child, fathers who were more involved in the child’s day to day care felt more competent in their parenting role and had a better relationship with their child).
There were links between family factors and persistent behavior problems in children. Children with lower mental abilities, higher excitability scores, higher incidence of respiratory infections and lower self sufficiency scores were more likely to have difficult behavior. However, when these factors are controlled for in the data analysis, behavior difficulties were worse in families with poor family cohesion, poor parent-child relationships, in poor housing and with low social support. They were also worse when mothers used passive coping strategies and tended to have neurotic personalities, when fathers were unemployed and when the family was experiencing additional stressful life events. In other words, the way in which parents coped and the family was functioning influenced behavior even when child characteristics have been taken into account.
Children in families with an active-recreational orientation, children with younger mothers and children with more siblings had wider social lives, even when child characteristics such as ability and behavior are considered. In other words, family factors influence children’s social lives even for the less able or more difficult children.
A recent longitudinal study of American children with Down syndrome up to 10 years of age has also identified the effects of family factors on the children’s development. Progress in self-sufficiency, communication and social skills were all influenced by family adaptability and emotional cohesiveness and mothers positive interactive style when teaching her child. The effects of these factors were pooled so that their individual importance cannot be identified. The reader may be interested to know that the children’s motor progress was not affected by the family or mothers characteristics.
Children and families influence each other
In summary, these research studies show that parent and family characteristics and coping styles not only influence the stress that a family experiences when raising a child with Down syndrome but they also affect the development of the child. Unfortunately, the way in which family strengths and child characteristics interact over time will tend to make matters better or worse. A family with many strengths at the time that a baby with Down syndrome is born will be able to cope in a way which reduces the sense of distress and leads to positive parenting. This in turn leads to better development and less behavior difficulties for the child, continuing to make the child more rewarding and life easier for the family. A family with many weaknesses at the time of the birth of a baby with Down syndrome will be less able to make a positive adjustment and feel able to cope. Their distress may lead to less effective parenting and, in turn, the child will make slower progress and be more at risk for behavior difficulties. The child’s difficulties become a greater burden and increase distress in the family.
These somewhat extreme examples highlight the point made at the beginning of this book that all families are transactional and dynamic systems, that the behavior of each individual affects the behavior of the others and that families change over time as they manage these interactions. The examples used also emphasize the importance of very early support for families to ensure that they are helped to make positive adjustments and supported with advice on effective parenting styles. The most vulnerable families are at significant risk of high levels of stress and steadily increasing problems if early support from families, communities and services is not available to them.
By: Sue Buckley